Every November, the same temptation arrives alongside the holiday deals: the little button at checkout that says "pay in 4." Buy now, pay later has become as routine as free shipping, and this year it is bigger than ever. Adobe forecasts that BNPL will drive more than $21 billion in holiday spending between November 1 and December 31, 2026, representing roughly 8% of a record $275.1 billion in projected U.S. online sales. That is a 6.6% increase from last year, and it tells you everything about how completely this payment method has embedded itself in the way Americans shop. Charlet Sanieoff has been watching these numbers closely, and what they reveal underneath the surface is cause for a serious, timely conversation - one that is especially urgent right now, as Black Friday and Cyber Monday arrive and inboxes fill with discounts that feel too good to pass up.
Charlet Sanieoff wants to be clear from the start: this is not an argument against using BNPL. It is a practical warning about what has changed in 2026, what the data says about how real people are struggling, and what you can do right now to make sure a holiday deal does not turn into a January financial hangover. The landscape has shifted in three significant ways this year - late payments are rising, BNPL loans are starting to affect credit scores, and borrowing costs across the board are higher. Understanding all three before you click that checkout button is the smartest financial move you can make this fall.
The Late Payment Problem Is Getting Worse, Not Better
The most striking piece of data Charlet Sanieoff wants you to sit with comes from LendingTree's March 2026 survey findings: 47% of BNPL users paid late at least once in the past year. That is up from 41% in 2025 and 34% in 2024. The trend is moving in one direction, and it is not a good one. To put it plainly, nearly half of people who use BNPL are slipping up on payments, and that number has been climbing steadily for two years.
The good news, if you can call it that, is that most late payments are brief. Among those who paid late, 72% say their most recent late payment was no more than about a week overdue. That detail is actually important and somewhat hopeful - it suggests most people are not falling into a deep financial hole. They are losing track. They are forgetting due dates, or the payment hits a day or two before payday. It is a cash flow timing problem as much as it is an affordability problem. That distinction matters because it is fixable.
What is harder to fix is the stacking problem. According to the same LendingTree data, 63% of BNPL users have held multiple loans at one time, and 25% have had three or more active simultaneously. When you are juggling three separate "pay in 4" plans from three different purchases, each with its own due date, the cognitive load alone increases the chance of missing something. Each individual payment might be $30 or $50 and feel completely manageable in isolation. Together, they can quietly consume several hundred dollars in a single month, often in ways that are hard to see until the damage is done.
Charlet Sanieoff also points to a troubling signal about how deeply BNPL has crept into everyday spending. Twenty-nine percent of BNPL users have used these loans for groceries, up from 25% a year earlier and just 14% two years ago. Among Gen Z users, that rate climbs to 38%. When people are financing food, it is no longer a convenience tool - it is a coping mechanism. The CFPB has separately documented that BNPL borrowers are significantly more likely than non-users to carry revolving credit card balances and to rely on overdraft, payday, and pawn loans. That paints a picture of financial fragility that should give every holiday shopper pause before adding another installment plan to the pile.
What's New in 2026 - BNPL and Your Credit Score
One of the most consequential changes Charlet Sanieoff is tracking this year is the emerging relationship between BNPL activity and credit scores. For most of BNPL's short history, these loans existed in a kind of credit reporting gray zone - they did not show up on your credit report, which meant they neither helped nor hurt your score. That is starting to change, and it is something every consumer should understand before the holiday shopping season is in full swing.
FICO launched two new scoring models this year: FICO Score 10 BNPL and FICO Score 10 T BNPL, both of which are specifically designed to incorporate buy now, pay later data. Separately, Affirm now reports its loans directly to Experian and TransUnion. The practical effect is still limited for now, because most lenders continue to use older scoring models that do not yet include BNPL data. Some payment industry experts caution that widespread adoption by lenders could take years. But the direction of travel is clear, and Charlet Sanieoff believes consumers should start thinking about their BNPL behavior as credit behavior - because that is exactly what it is becoming.
What this means in practice: paying your BNPL installments on time may eventually help your credit score, and missing them may hurt it. The specific outcome depends on which BNPL provider you use and whether that provider reports to the bureaus. Before you sign up for a new plan this holiday season, it is worth taking 60 seconds to find out your provider's reporting policy - especially if you plan to apply for a mortgage, auto loan, or any major credit product in 2027. A string of late BNPL payments recorded this November and December could be sitting in your credit file when a lender pulls your report six months from now.
The delinquency data from lenders themselves reinforces the concern. At Affirm, loans 30 or more days past due rose 35 basis points sequentially to 2.9%, even while the company's gross merchandise volume jumped 34% to $14.4 billion. Block, the parent company of Afterpay, reported consumer lending originations of $19.0 billion, up 40% year over year. Volume is growing fast, and so is the number of accounts falling behind.
The Rate Environment Makes Every Missed Payment More Expensive
Charlet Sanieoff wants to draw attention to a background factor that makes the BNPL picture more complicated this fall: the broader interest rate environment. As of late October 2026, the Federal Reserve left its target range for the federal funds rate at 3.75% to 4.00%, holding the U.S. prime rate at 7.00%. Sixteen of eighteen Fed officials projected at least one more rate increase before year end, with the next decision scheduled for December 8 and 9 - right in the middle of holiday shopping season.
Why does this matter for BNPL users? The classic BNPL pitch is that the plan itself is interest-free, and for many pay-in-4 products that is technically true. But the interest-free framing breaks down the moment a consumer pays off a BNPL balance using a credit card. The average APR for new credit card offers reached 23.96% in October. If you miss a BNPL due date, scramble to cover it with your credit card, and then carry that balance forward, the "free" installment plan has just become one of the most expensive forms of credit available. The interest-free label is only accurate if everything goes perfectly on schedule.
New York State has moved to address some of these concerns at the regulatory level. On February 23, 2026, New York regulators proposed new rules implementing the Buy-Now-Pay-Later Act, which would subject BNPL loans to a 16% interest-rate cap when they charge interest. The rules are expected to take effect 180 days after a final rule is adopted. At the federal level, the CFPB issued a rule in 2024 that treated certain BNPL products like credit cards, but that rule was later withdrawn in May 2025. The regulatory picture remains uneven, which means consumers cannot yet rely on consistent legal protections and need to protect themselves.
Charlet Sanieoff's 7 Practical Rules for Holiday BNPL Use
Charlet Sanieoff believes that informed consumers make better decisions, and that the goal of understanding these risks is not to avoid BNPL entirely but to use it deliberately. With that in mind, here are seven practical rules to carry into your holiday shopping:
- Apply the two-paycheck test. If the full purchase price would not fit comfortably within your next two paychecks, that is a signal the item is outside your current budget. Splitting the payment does not change the underlying math.
- Limit yourself to one active plan at a time. A quarter of users are currently juggling three or more simultaneous BNPL loans. That is precisely how small, manageable payments quietly become a missed one.
- Do not use pay-in-4 for groceries or everyday essentials. If you are relying on installment loans for food or utility bills, that is a signal your monthly budget needs attention, not a workaround.
- Turn on autopay and align due dates with your payday. Since most late payments happen within a week of the due date, a simple calendar alert or automatic payment can prevent the majority of them. Many providers allow you to shift your due date - ask.
- Ask for a late fee waiver if you slip. LendingTree data shows that 90% of people who asked to have a late fee waived had it reduced or eliminated entirely. The worst they can say is no.
- Know your provider's credit reporting policy before you buy. This is especially important if you are planning any major loan application in 2027. Check whether your BNPL provider reports to the credit bureaus and what they report.
- Pay off last year's holiday debt before adding new debt. A College Investor survey found that 38% of shoppers are still paying off purchases from last holiday season, including 21% still carrying BNPL balances. If you are in that group, make clearing last year's debt your first priority and consider starting a small monthly sinking fund for 2027 holiday expenses.
Charlet Sanieoff knows these rules can sound simple on a list and genuinely difficult to follow when you are staring down a 40% discount on something you have wanted to buy for months. That tension is real. But so is the regret that follows an impulsive BNPL purchase - 54% of BNPL users say they have regretted a purchase made this way, up from 48% in 2025. And so is the financial stress of still paying for last Christmas while this Christmas is already arriving.
Making the Holiday Season Work for You, Not Against You
The bigger picture that Charlet Sanieoff wants to leave you with is this: BNPL is not inherently dangerous. Used with intention, it can be a genuinely useful tool for smoothing out a large purchase across a few weeks without paying interest. The problem is that the conditions around it have changed in ways that are not obvious at the checkout screen. Late payments are more common. Credit reporting is beginning. The rate environment means mistakes are more costly. And the emotional pull of holiday deals makes all of it harder to navigate clearly.
Adobe's data shows that many consumers are using BNPL not just for gifts but to stock up on discounted essentials - household goods, personal care items, and similar products. That is a reasonable use of a good sale. But it still needs to fit within a budget you have actually mapped out. Forty-three percent of Americans are at least considering a BNPL loan this month according to LendingTree's October 2026 tracker. That is a lot of people about to make a financial decision that could follow them into the new year.
Charlet Sanieoff's core message this Black Friday and Cyber Monday season is a straightforward one: the deal is only as good as the plan behind it. Know what you are agreeing to, know how it affects your credit, know what it will cost you if something goes wrong, and make sure the payment schedule matches your actual cash flow. The holidays are worth celebrating. A January debt hangover is not.
If this post helped you think through your holiday spending, share it with someone who could use a financial reality check before the big shopping days hit. And check back for Charlet Sanieoff's ongoing coverage of personal finance, credit, and the economic trends shaping everyday financial decisions.
Search
Recent Posts
Never Miss A Post!
Sign up for free and be the first to get notified about updates.
Newsletter
Share Post
Featured Videos
All Tags












